Connect with us

Politics

BREAKING: Supreme Court Ignores Details Of January 6 And Trump’s Role In It

Published

on

The gory details of Jan. 6 — the mobs armed with bear mace and flagpoles-turned-spears, the narrow escape by lawmakers and Vice President Mike Pence, the blood, the injuries, the deaths — got short shrift at Thursday’s oral arguments before the Supreme Court.

The justices spent nearly all of the two-plus-hours in the more abstract world of the legal arguments surrounding the disqualification clause: whether states can enforce it against a federal candidate, whether the president counts as an “officer” under the Constitution, if Congress needs to pass a law to enforce it. The basic facts of why this case came before them — Trump’s actions and speech on and leading up to the most violent coup attempt since Reconstruction — faded into the background.

Given the liberals’ unusual alignment with their right-wing colleagues on some of the central questions, that omission may ultimately play to the detriment of the side fighting to uphold the Colorado Supreme Court’s disqualification ruling.

It also somewhat breaks with the briefing on the case, where many pages were devoted to whether Jan. 6 constituted an insurrection under this clause and, if so, whether Trump’s role can be considered “engaging” in it.

Advertisement

The first mention of those questions came courtesy of Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson nearly an hour into the arguments, and the harshest description of the events that transpired from Trump’s lawyer, Jonathan Mitchell, in response.

“The Colorado Supreme Court concluded that the violent attempts of the petitioner’s supporters in this case to halt the count on January 6 qualified as an insurrection as defined by Section 3,” Jackson said, asking whether Mitchell agreed.

The two briefly sparred on Mitchell’s argument that it didn’t qualify — “a chaotic effort to overthrow the government is not an insurrection?” she asked incredulously, when he said the effort had to be “organized” — but he still concluded by making the strongest condemnation of Jan. 6 raised throughout the arguments.

“This was a riot — it was not an insurrection — the events were shameful, criminal, violent, all of those things, but it did not qualify as an insurrection as that term is used in Section 3,” he said.

Advertisement

Minutes after that colloquy, Colorado petitioners’ lawyer Jason Murray nodded at the events in his opening: “For the first time since the War of 1812, our nation’s capital came under violent assault. For the first time in history, the attack was incited by a sitting President of the United States to disrupt the peaceful transfer of presidential power.”

But that was largely it. The justices stayed far away from the details of Trump’s involvement and the attack itself, and Murray — his opportunities limited by the justices’ bombardment of questions about states’ ability to enforce the disqualification clause — didn’t press it.

This case offers the justices a variety of procedural offramps that it long seemed likely they’d prefer to take if they wanted to come down against disqualification. If it gives them a similar result, why not use states’ inability to enforce the clause or Trump not counting as an officer, rather than delivering a much more charged ruling replete with details about the Jan. 6 attack and Trump’s culpability?

But by losing that piece, Colorado also lost its most compelling argument: the horror of having an insurrectionist clamber back into the White House after siccing his supporters, armed and deluded, on Congress, to take back by force an election he convinced them he’d won.

Advertisement
Continue Reading
Advertisement
Advertisement
Politics23 hours ago

BREAKING: “I am starting my political career from here” – Laide Bakare speaks following new appointment with Osun State, pens message to Governor Adeleke

Politics23 hours ago

BREAKING: Arewa Economic Forum Asks Tinubu To Reconsider Fuel Subsidy Removal

Politics23 hours ago

BREAKING: Armed Militia: Court Orders FG To File Charges Against Miyyeti Allah’s Bodejo Within 7 days

Politics23 hours ago

BREAKING: Senate Committee on Constitution Review sets 24 months for exercise

Politics23 hours ago

BREAKING: “Tinubu Champions Accountability and Democracy at ECOWAS Judges’ Meeting”

Politics23 hours ago

BREAKING: Group Calls on Governors and Lawmakers to Act on Fuel Subsidy Removal

Politics23 hours ago

BREAKING: INEC Opens Up On IReV Failure During 2023 Presidential Election

Politics23 hours ago

BREAKING: How My Late Dad Made Me Go Into Politics

Politics23 hours ago

BREAKING: Taraba Assembly passes Takum chieftaincy rotation bill

Latest News23 hours ago

BREAKING: Proliferation of drugs fuel banditry, terrorism – NDLEA

Politics23 hours ago

BREAKING: Balarabe’s strides at FCE Zaria

Politics23 hours ago

BREAKING: Senate rejects bill to extend NASS workers’ years of service

Politics23 hours ago

BREAKING: Again, Customs intercepts Niger Republic bound grains

Politics23 hours ago

BREAKING: Ex-Kwara Governor, Ahmed Chartered Private Jets With N1.6bn–EFCC

Politics23 hours ago

BREAKING: Kanayo Kanayo opens up on amount of money Peter Obi gave him for his mother’s funeral

Politics23 hours ago

BREAKING: Govs tackle Akpabio, deny receiving FG N1tn lifeline;military warns against coup

Politics23 hours ago

BREAKING: Kaduna Deputy Speaker assures public of readiness to pass GEO bill, tasks women on visibility

Politics23 hours ago

BREAKING: The Authentic Delegates Of The Party Voted For Me, They Wanted To Disenfranchise Them- Philip Shaibu

Politics23 hours ago

BREAKING: Governor Buni’s exemplary initiatives

Politics23 hours ago

BREAKING: Sanwo-Olu Rolls Out Relief Measures As He Reduces Work Days For Lagos Civil Servants

Politics23 hours ago

BREAKING: The Authentic Delegates Of The Party Voted For Me, They Wanted To Disenfranchise Them- Philip Shaibu

Politics23 hours ago

BREAKING: “I am starting my political career from here” – Laide Bakare speaks following new appointment with Osun State, pens message to Governor Adeleke

Politics23 hours ago

BREAKING: Armed Militia: Court Orders FG To File Charges Against Miyyeti Allah’s Bodejo Within 7 days

Politics23 hours ago

BREAKING: Ex-Kwara Governor, Ahmed Chartered Private Jets With N1.6bn–EFCC

Politics23 hours ago

BREAKING: Arewa Economic Forum Asks Tinubu To Reconsider Fuel Subsidy Removal

Politics23 hours ago

BREAKING: Kaduna Deputy Speaker assures public of readiness to pass GEO bill, tasks women on visibility

Politics23 hours ago

BREAKING: Again, Customs intercepts Niger Republic bound grains

Politics23 hours ago

BREAKING: Balarabe’s strides at FCE Zaria

Politics23 hours ago

BREAKING: Taraba Assembly passes Takum chieftaincy rotation bill

Politics23 hours ago

BREAKING: Senate rejects bill to extend NASS workers’ years of service

Politics23 hours ago

BREAKING: Govs tackle Akpabio, deny receiving FG N1tn lifeline;military warns against coup

Politics23 hours ago

BREAKING: Kanayo Kanayo opens up on amount of money Peter Obi gave him for his mother’s funeral

Latest News23 hours ago

BREAKING: Proliferation of drugs fuel banditry, terrorism – NDLEA

Politics23 hours ago

BREAKING: Senate Committee on Constitution Review sets 24 months for exercise

Politics23 hours ago

BREAKING: Sanwo-Olu Rolls Out Relief Measures As He Reduces Work Days For Lagos Civil Servants

Politics23 hours ago

BREAKING: INEC Opens Up On IReV Failure During 2023 Presidential Election

Politics23 hours ago

BREAKING: How My Late Dad Made Me Go Into Politics

Politics23 hours ago

BREAKING: “Tinubu Champions Accountability and Democracy at ECOWAS Judges’ Meeting”

Politics23 hours ago

BREAKING: Governor Buni’s exemplary initiatives

Politics23 hours ago

BREAKING: Group Calls on Governors and Lawmakers to Act on Fuel Subsidy Removal

Trending